The Best Anglers Never Stop Learning

The Best Anglers Never Stop Learning

Why Do I Keep Losing Bonefish After the Hookset?

Question

I’ve had some success getting bonefish to eat the fly, but my landing ratio is terrible. Sometimes I strip-set, feel the weight, and then—nothing. Other times, I hold on for a second, only to have the fish pop off midway through its first run. Am I setting too hard? Not hard enough? What’s the right way to drive the hook home and keep the fish pinned?

Answer by:

Marshall Mcutchin
Marshall Mcutchin
Founder of MidCurrent
40 Years of Experience

Hooking a bonefish is just step one—keeping it pinned is where most anglers struggle. Bonefish have hard, rubbery mouths, and if you don’t drive the hook in properly or maintain the right tension, you’ll lose a lot of fish.

  • Set hard, but not with your rod: A proper strip-set is everything. A quick, firm pull straight back with your line hand is what sinks the hook. A trout-set (lifting the rod tip) will pull the fly away before it has a chance to dig in.
  • Use the right hook: If you’re losing fish on the run, check your hooks. Some bonefish flies use thin-wire hooks, which bend out under heavy pressure. Use a strong, chemically-sharpened hook designed for saltwater.
  • Keep your rod tip low on the run: After the hookset, your first instinct might be to raise the rod. Don’t. Keeping the tip low reduces slack and maintains pressure as the fish takes off.
  • Let them take line smoothly: A bonefish’s first run is blistering. If your drag is too tight, you’ll break off. If it’s too loose, the hook can wiggle free. Adjust your drag so the fish can run, but with steady resistance.
  • Bow to the fish on jumps: If a bonefish makes an unexpected jump, briefly lowering the rod (like with tarpon) can keep it from throwing the fly.

Final Thought

Bonefish are built for speed, so the key to landing them is a solid strip-set, steady pressure, and controlled drag tension. The better you get at managing hook penetration and line control, the higher your landing ratio will be.

No recommended resources available.

Ask An Expert

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Become a Member

Sign up for full access to the Learning Center
and all the FlyBrary Content.